119. Default Mode Network vs. Task Positive Network | How our brains balance mind wandering and focused attention

The interplay between the Default Mode Network (DMN) and the Task Positive Network (TPN) is crucial for our cognitive and emotional health. The DMN, active during restful states and wandering mind, facilitates introspection, memory recall, and creativity, serving as a foundational element in our mental processes. On the other hand, the TPN takes charge during focused, goal-oriented tasks, enabling attention, decision-making, and problem-solving. They operate in balance – when one is active, the other quiescent and this dynamic is essential for optimal mental functioning.

However, imbalances in these networks can lead to mental health challenges. For instance, excessive DMN activity is linked to conditions like depression and anxiety, where rumination and negative self-referential thoughts prevail. In contrast, overreliance on the TPN without adequate rest can lead to burnout and stress.

Mindfulness meditation offers a practical approach to equilibrating the DMN and TPN, promoting mental well-being by fostering a state of alert relaxation and enhancing self-awareness. Moreover, incorporating regular breaks into the workday, particularly those that allow for mental disengagement from task-focused activities, is vital for sustaining cognitive performance and preventing decision fatigue. Engaging in activities that stimulate the DMN, such as spending time in nature or practicing mindfulness, during these breaks can further enhance cognitive restoration and emotional balance.

Awake and Aware | Our 2024 Live Event

Join us at Awake and Aware 2024, a transformative 3-day workshop from May 1st to 3rd in Bend, Oregon. Focusing on interactive experiences, this event offers a unique opportunity to reset, reflect, and connect with like-minded individuals. Limited slots. 

Website: Awakeandawarebend.com

Early bird discount code: FULLYAWAKE24. $100 off registration. Expires Jan 31, 2024

CME: Yes! This is a CME event.

Love medicine, but the job itself leaves a lot to be desired?

I work with many docs in your shoes. To learn more about 1-on-1 coaching, start here.

The Driveway Debrief

Leave work at work. Be more present at home.

Our free 10-minute guided exercise to shake off the residue of the day.

Learn More Here

We Discuss:

What is the Default Mode Network?

• Network of Brain Regions: The DMN isn’t a single brain part but a network of interconnected regions, akin to suburbs linked by highways.
• Active During Rest: It becomes particularly active when we’re not focused on external tasks, engaging with our inner thoughts or “inner world.”
• Inner Voice and Brain Chatter: The DMN is involved in the internal dialogue or stream of consciousness that includes thoughts, memories, and self-referential processing.
• Essential for Healthy Brain Function: Despite its association with mind wandering, the DMN is crucial for normal brain operations, aiding in tasks like introspection, daydreaming, and memory formation.
• Autopilot Mode: It’s engaged during periods of rest and is fundamental for integrating external world events with self-referential thoughts.
• Link to Creativity: The activities associated with the DMN, such as daydreaming and mind wandering, can enhance creativity.
• Potential for Negative Impact: While beneficial in many respects, unchecked activity in the DMN can lead to rumination, particularly problematic in mood disorders, where it can exacerbate negative thought patterns.

What is the Task Positive Network?

• Activation During Tasks: The TPN becomes active when we are engaged in tasks that demand attention, cognitive control, and goal-directed behaviors, essentially serving as the brain’s “mission control center” during task-focused activities.
• Executive Functioning: It’s instrumental in executive functions, which include planning, decision-making, and problem-solving.
• Contrast to DMN: While the Default Mode Network is active during rest and internal reflection, the TPN is engaged during focused, goal-oriented tasks, highlighting a functional dichotomy between the brain’s networks.

Interplay of the TPN and DMN

• Oppositional Functioning: The TPN and DMN operate in a seesaw-like manner or what can be described as a dynamic equilibrium, where the activation of one typically leads to the suppression of the other.
• Balance is Crucial: Maintaining a balance between the two networks is essential for optimal mental functioning. Excessive DMN activity can lead to overindulgence in introspection or daydreaming when focus is required, whereas too much TPN activity can cause mental fatigue, stress, and even burnout.
• Restorative Functions of DMN: The DMN plays a critical role during rest, contributing to memory consolidation, self-reflection, and emotional processing. An imbalance favoring continuous TPN engagement can disrupt these important processes.
• DMN Beyond Humans: Interestingly, the DMN is not unique to humans; it’s also found in other mammals, including primates and rodents, indicating its fundamental role in brain function across species.

Default Mode Network out of Balance | Mental Illness

• Depression: In depression, there’s often heightened activity within the DMN, especially in areas related to self-referential thought and rumination. This hyperactivity may contribute to the persistent negative thinking and excessive self-focus seen in depressive disorders.
• Anxiety Disorders: Anxiety disorders might involve disrupted connectivity within the DMN, leading to excessive worry and anticipatory anxiety. The altered patterns of activity and connectivity can perpetuate the cycle of anxiety.
• Schizophrenia: Schizophrenia is associated with dysfunctional activity in the DMN, particularly a failure to deactivate the DMN during tasks that require outward attention. This persistent activation may contribute to symptoms such as hallucinations and delusions.
• Psychopathy and Antisocial Behavior: Individuals with psychopathy show differences in their DMN, particularly in areas related to moral judgment. These abnormalities may underlie some of the antisocial behaviors observed in psychopathy.

The Neurophysiology Behind How Taking a Small Step of Action Can Decrease Rumination and Anxiety

• DMN and Rumination: Heightened DMN activity is associated with increased rumination and anxiety, as this network is involved in self-referential thoughts and internal focus.
• Activating the TPN: Engaging in a small, goal-directed action activates the TPN, which shifts the brain’s focus from internal, ruminative processes to external, goal-oriented tasks.
• Reducing Anxiety: This shift can help reduce the symptoms of anxiety and rumination by moving away from inward-focused thought patterns to outward-focused actions.
• Enhancing Cognitive Control: Taking action enhances cognitive control and can improve various cognitive functions that are often impaired by anxiety and worry, such as attention, problem-solving, and memory.

The Default Mode Network and Insomnia

• Racing Mind in Insomnia: People with insomnia often experience a racing mind, rumination, or unwanted thoughts at night.
• DMN Involvement: The DMN, known for its role in self-referential thoughts and mind wandering, is implicated in these experiences, suggesting it might not deactivate properly in individuals with insomnia.
• Research Findings: There is a significant correlation between an overactive DMN and poor sleep quality, indicating that increased connectivity within the DMN may predict sleep disturbances.
• Difficulty Transitioning to Sleep: An overactive DMN might interfere with the brain’s ability to smoothly transition into sleep due to persistent self-focused thoughts and a failure to “switch off.”
• Counting Sheep Myth: Contrary to popular belief, counting sheep—a task-focused activity—does not help with falling asleep. Research has shown that it might actually delay sleep onset.
• Effective Techniques: Imagining relaxing scenes, such as a peaceful waterfall or a pleasant holiday, has been found more effective in aiding sleep. This suggests that engaging in a mentally soothing activity can facilitate sleep onset better than trying to actively distract the mind with repetitive tasks.
• Suppressing Thoughts: Efforts to suppress worries or forcibly shut off thinking can prolong the time it takes to fall asleep, highlighting the counterproductive nature of trying to control thoughts too rigidly.

What Happens with the DMN and TPN in Meditation?

• DMN Activity in Meditation: Mindfulness meditation is associated with reduced activity in the DMN, which is typically engaged during mind wandering and self-referential thoughts. This reduction aligns with the meditative practice of noticing thoughts as they arise and then returning focus to a meditation object such as the breath
• Decrease in Mind Wandering:  Functional MRI studies have shown that experienced meditators exhibit decreased DMN activity, suggesting a decrease in mind wandering. A subsequent study in 2012 highlighted that mindfulness training enhances awareness of attention shifts, allowing practitioners to recognize and redirect from mind wandering, a DMN activity, more effectively.
• Cognitive Elements of Mindfulness: Mindfulness involves a cycle of mind wandering, awareness of this wandering, shifting attention back to a focal point (like the breath), and maintaining sustained attention. This cycle, repeated during meditation, trains the brain in both focus and awareness of mind wandering.
• Improvements in Brain Coordination: Mindfulness can improve the coordination and communication between different regions of the DMN, potentially enhancing cognitive and emotional processing even after meditation sessions.
• Cognitive Distancing: Mindfulness practice can also foster a more detached and non-judgmental perspective towards self-referential thoughts, aiding in cognitive distancing and acceptance. This shift can reduce the impact of repetitive negative thinking and improve overall mental well-being.

The Task Positive Network’s Role in Meditation

• Meditation and TPN: During mindfulness meditation, the TPN is engaged in a unique way. The practice involves concentrating on a meditation object (like the breath) and noticing when the mind wanders, then gently redirecting attention back to the focus point.
• Restful Awareness: Mindfulness meditation introduces a state of “restful awareness,” where there’s focused attention without the cognitive strain of problem-solving or decision-making. This presents a form of cognitive rest that’s different from passive relaxation or distraction.
• Balanced Activation: The practice of mindfulness, through its cycles of focused attention and open monitoring, promotes a balanced activation between the TPN and DMN.
• Contrast with Break Activities: Common break activities like checking social media may seem restful but actually continue to engage the TPN, leading to further fatigue. 

Why Your Task Positive Network is Begging You to Take a Break in the Workday

• Continuous Task Saturation: Most professionals, especially in high-stress environments like healthcare, experience continuous task saturation, leading to decision fatigue and decreased efficiency.
• Breaks Are Essential: Contrary to the belief that there’s no time for breaks, incorporating them into your day is crucial and possible, even in busy settings. Breaks need to be prioritized and planned, similar to other critical tasks.
• Structured Breaks: To ensure breaks are taken, they should be scheduled or triggered by consistent daily events. This can be facilitated by setting alarms or using natural breaks in the day as reminders.
• Cultural Expectations: In many work cultures, there’s a tendency to value powering through without breaks. However, taking breaks should be seen as a sign of understanding one’s human limitations and a strategy for maintaining peak performance.
• Benefits of Breaks: Effective breaks can make work more enjoyable, increase efficiency, and improve patient care in healthcare settings. They are a sign of professional maturity and self-awareness.
• Decision Fatigue: As the day progresses, mental vigilance and decision-making capacity wane, leading to potential compromises in work quality. Regular breaks can mitigate this decline.
• Antibiotic Prescribing: A 2014 study by Linder et al., published in JAMA Internal Medicine, investigates the impact of the time of day on physicians’ decisions to prescribe antibiotics for viral upper respiratory infections (URIs), conditions that typically do not benefit from antibiotics. The analysis of primary care appointments revealed a significant trend: the probability of physicians prescribing antibiotics for URIs increased from the morning to the late afternoon. Early in the day, antibiotics were prescribed less frequently, but by the end of the day, the rate of prescriptions rose markedly, despite the lack of clinical benefit for such viral infections. This pattern suggests that decision fatigue and time pressures accumulating over the workday may lead to a higher likelihood of unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions.
• Don’t be the Last Case of the Day: A 2011 study by Danziger, Levav, and Avnaim-Pesso, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, examines the influence of breaks on judicial decision-making. Analyzing over a thousand parole board decisions, the researchers found a clear pattern: at the start of the day or after a break, judges were likely to grant requests about 65% of the time. However, as the session progressed, the rate of favorable rulings steadily decreased to nearly zero. Following a break, the likelihood of a favorable ruling would reset to 65%. This pattern suggests that breaks, seemingly unrelated to case details, significantly impact judges’ decisions, potentially due to reduced decision fatigue. 
• Practical Implications: Understanding the need for breaks and implementing them can lead to significant improvements in work quality, personal well-being, and overall job satisfaction.

How to Take a Break That Effectively Recharges Your Task Positive Network

• Disengage from Work: Avoid work-related discussions and tasks during your break to ensure you’re not inadvertently keeping your TPN engaged.
• Avoid Digital Screens: Limit the use of phones and other digital devices as they can keep your mind in an active, task-focused state rather than allowing it to recharge.
• Engage the Default Mode Network: Activities that promote a state of unfocused rest, such as daydreaming or gazing into nature, can help recharge your focus capacity by activating the Default Mode Network (DMN).
• Listen to Natural Sounds: Sounds from nature can help activate the DMN and stimulate the parasympathetic nervous system, aiding in relaxation and mental restoration.
• Spend Time Outdoors: If possible, take your break outside in a natural setting. Nature has a profound restorative effect on the mind and body.
• Practice Mindfulness: Meditation or mindful breathing exercises can help balance the TPN and DMN, fostering a state of calm and focused attention post-break.
• Physical Activity: Brief, moderate physical activity can help rejuvenate cognitive performance and alleviate the mental fatigue associated with prolonged focused tasks.
• Social Interaction: Socializing during breaks can be beneficial, but it’s crucial to steer clear of work-related topics to ensure your brain gets a genuine respite from task-focused activities.
• Micro Breaks: In extremely busy environments, even short breaks of a minute or two can be beneficial. These micro breaks, taken periodically, can help maintain cognitive performance.
• Intentional Break Planning: Make taking breaks a deliberate part of your day. Schedule them like any other important activity to ensure they happen.

.

References 

1. Sheline YI, et al. The default mode network and self-referential processes in depression. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009;106(6):1942-1947.
2. Liao W, et al. Altered default mode network connectivity in patients with generalized anxiety disorder: An fMRI study. J Affect Disord. 2010;127(1-3):332-339.
3. Whitfield-Gabrieli S, et al. Hyperactivity and hyperconnectivity of the default network in schizophrenia and in first-degree relatives of persons with schizophrenia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009;106(4):1279-1284.
4. Kennedy DP, Courchesne E. The intrinsic functional organization of the brain is altered in autism. Neuroimage. 2008;39(4):1877-1885.
5. Pujol J, et al. Breakdown in the brain network subserving moral judgment in criminal psychopathy. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2012;7(8):917-923.
6. Baird B, et al. Inspired by distraction: Mind wandering facilitates creative incubation. Psychol Sci. 2012;23(10):1117-1122.
7. Goldin PR, et al. Neural bases of social anxiety disorder: Emotional reactivity and cognitive regulation during social and physical threat. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2009;66(2):170-180.
8. Killgore WDS, et al. Functional connectivity of the default mode network predicts subsequent polysomnographically measured sleep in people with symptoms of insomnia. Neuroreport. 2023;34(14):734-740.
9. Marques DR, et al. Insomnia Disorder and Brain’s Default-Mode Network. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep. 2018;18(8):45. doi:10.1007/s11910-018-0861-3.
10. Chaudhry S. Counting sheep will not help you sleep. Student BMJ. 2002;10.
11. Brewer JA, et al. Meditation experience is associated with differences in default mode network activity and connectivity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011;108(50):20254-20259.
12. Hasenkamp W, et al. Mind wandering and attention during focused meditation: A fine-grained temporal analysis of fluctuating cognitive states. Neuroimage. 2012;59(1):750-760.
13. Jang JH, et al. Increased default mode network connectivity associated with meditation. Neurosci Lett. 2011;487(3):358-362.
14. Farb NA, et al. Attending to the present: Mindfulness meditation reveals distinct neural modes of self-reference. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2007;2(4):313-322.
15. Rahrig H, et al. Meta-analytic evidence that mindfulness training alters resting state default mode network connectivity. Sci Rep. 2022;12:12260.
16. Linder JA, et al. Time of day and the decision to prescribe antibiotics. JAMA Intern Med. 2014;174(12):2029-2031.
17. Danziger S, et al. Extraneous factors in judicial decisions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011;108(17):6889-6892.
18. Gao L, et al. Effects of Rest-Break on Mental Fatigue Recovery Determined by a Novel Temporal Brain Network Analysis of Dynamic Functional Connectivity. IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2022;30:157-166.
19. Li J, et al. Mid-Task Break Improves Global Integration of Functional Connectivity in Lower Alpha Band. Front Hum Neurosci. 2016;10:304.
20. Gonzalez-Castillo J, et al. Task-based dynamic functional connectivity: Recent findings and open questions. Neuroimage. 2018;180(Pt B):526-533.
21. Hosseini GS, et al. Effective connectivity of mental fatigue: Dynamic causal modeling of EEG data. Technol Health Care. 2019;27(4):343-352.
22. Matsui T, et al. A novel concept of brain glycogen supercompensation for enhancing endurance performance of athletes. Nutrition. 2012;28(7-8):668–673.